Capri vs Ischia: 7 Key Differences to Choose Your Perfect Italian Island Getaway in 2025

Planning a trip to the Bay of Naples? Choosing between Capri and Ischia can be tough. These beautiful Italian islands each offer unique experiences in the Mediterranean.

Ischia is much larger at 46 square kilometers compared to Capri’s 10 square kilometers, giving travelers more space to explore with six distinct towns versus Capri’s two. While Capri has gained legendary status for its glamour and romance, Ischia tends to be less crowded and more budget-friendly, with options for every price range.

Many travelers find Ischia offers more diverse activities across its larger landscape. However, Capri’s stunning scenery and iconic status in Southern Italy can’t be denied. Both islands provide incredible Mediterranean experiences, but your perfect choice depends on whether you prefer Ischia’s relaxed authenticity or Capri’s dramatic beauty.

Geography and Landscape

Capri and Ischia have dramatically different geographic profiles despite their shared Mediterranean location. The islands contrast sharply in size, topography, and natural features, which significantly impacts the visitor experience.

Island Topography

Ischia dominates with its impressive 46 square kilometers, more than four times larger than Capri’s modest 10 square kilometers. This size difference means Ischia accommodates six distinct towns, while Capri has just two. Ischia’s volcanic origins are evident in its dramatic landscape dominated by Mount Epomeo, which rises to 789 meters. The mountain’s slopes are covered with lush greenery and vineyards.

Capri, though smaller, features a rugged landscape with limestone cliffs that plunge directly into azure waters. Mount Solaro, at 589 meters, stands at its highest point, offering panoramic views of the Bay of Naples.

The island’s compact nature means its dramatic features feel more concentrated and immediately accessible. Both islands share the Mediterranean climate that blesses them with mild winters and warm summers, perfect for tourism.

Iconic Landmarks

Ischia’s volcanic identity shapes its most distinctive landmarks. Natural thermal springs bubble throughout the island, creating hot spots on certain beaches where water temperature rises noticeably.

These geothermal features have transformed Ischia into a wellness destination with numerous thermal bath resorts utilizing naturally heated waters. The massive Aragonese Castle, perched dramatically on a volcanic islet connected to Ischia by a stone bridge, provides a stunning historical centerpiece visible from much of the island.

Capri counters with the world-famous Blue Grotto (Grotta Azzurra), a sea cave illuminated by an otherworldly blue light. The Faraglioni rock formations – three towering stone structures rising from the sea – have become Capri’s most photographed natural landmark. The Gardens of Augustus and the dramatic Via Krupp switchback path carved into the cliffside showcase how Capri’s compact geography has been enhanced by human design.

Historical Significance

Capri and Ischia boast fascinating histories stretching back thousands of years, attracting visitors interested in more than just beaches and scenery. These islands have played host to emperors, artists, and everyday people who left their mark in stone and story.

Historic Sites and Ruins

Capri’s most famous historic attraction is Villa Jovis, an impressive imperial residence built by Emperor Tiberius in the 1st century AD. Perched on a cliff 1,200 feet above sea level, this sprawling complex once covered 75,000 square feet. Today, visitors can explore the ruins and imagine the lavish Roman lifestyle.

Ischia counters with the magnificent Aragonese Castle built on a rocky islet in 474 BC. The fortress was later expanded by Alfonso V of Aragon in the 15th century. Unlike Capri’s Roman focus, Ischia’s history includes Greek settlers who arrived in the 8th century BC.

Both islands have connections to the mainland’s history. While Capri became a retreat for Roman elites, Ischia developed as a strategic military outpost. Ancient geographer Strabo even theorized that Capri was once connected to the Amalfi Coast—a theory later supported by geological evidence.

Ischia tends to showcase its medieval and Renaissance history, while Capri emphasizes its imperial Roman past. This difference gives each island a distinct historical atmosphere that appeals to different types of history buffs.

Accessibility and Transportation

Getting around Capri and Ischia requires some planning, especially if you have mobility concerns. Each island has distinct transportation options and accessibility challenges that can impact your travel experience.

Traveling to and from the Islands

Both Capri and Ischia are accessible by ferry services from Naples and Sorrento. Ferries to Capri are more frequent during high season, with journeys taking about 40 minutes from Sorrento and 80 minutes from Naples. Ischia ferries typically run from Naples, with trips lasting around 90 minutes.

Ferry prices differ slightly. Capri ferries tend to be a bit pricier, ranging from €20-€24 one-way, while Ischia ferries might cost €18-€22. During rough weather, ferry services to both islands can be disrupted or canceled.

When booking your travel, consider checking flight and ferry combinations to get the best deals if you’re coming from further away. For travelers with mobility issues, Capri’s ferries often provide better assistance for boarding and disembarking.

Navigating the Islands

Vehicles are heavily restricted on Capri. The main port, Marina Grande, connects to Capri Town via funicular, bus, or taxi.

Buses also run between Capri Town and Anacapri. Most attractions require walking on sometimes steep paths, which can be challenging for those with mobility concerns.

Ischia, being larger, offers more transportation options. Public buses connect all six towns, and taxis are readily available. The island also permits more vehicle traffic, making navigating generally easier for those with mobility limitations.

For mobility-impaired visitors, Ischia tends to be more accessible overall. Its flatter terrain in many areas and more extensive bus network make exploring easier.

Capri has implemented some accessibility improvements, especially around Marina Grande and Marina Piccola, but many attractions still require climbing steps or steep paths. Both islands offer boat taxis that can transport you between beach areas, providing a scenic alternative to land transportation.

Accommodation Options

Both islands offer distinct lodging experiences reflecting their unique character, with notable differences in price points and styles to suit various travel preferences.

Luxury Hotels

Capri excels at high-end accommodations. The island boasts several five-star properties with stunning views of the Mediterranean. Many luxury hotels in Capri feature infinity pools overlooking the sea, exclusive restaurants, and spa facilities.

Prices on Capri tend to be significantly higher, especially during peak season (May-September). Expect to pay premium rates for that picture-perfect view of the Faraglioni rocks or Marina Grande. The JK Place Capri and Capri Palace are standouts for travelers seeking ultimate luxury.

Ischia offers luxury, too, but at more reasonable prices. The island’s thermal spas are often incorporated into its upscale hotels, making them popular wellness destinations. Many high-end properties in Ischia provide more space and amenities for your money compared to similar-category hotels on Capri.

Quaint Bed and Breakfasts

Ischia excels in the B&B category with charming, family-run options scattered throughout the island. These accommodations often provide an authentic glimpse into local life at budget-friendly prices. Many occupy converted farmhouses or historic buildings, offering character you won’t find in chain hotels.

Hosts in Ischia typically provide personalized recommendations and sometimes even home-cooked meals featuring local specialties. The western and southern parts of the island have particularly charming options with garden settings.

Capri’s B&Bs tend to be more upscale and design-focused, though still providing that personal touch. They’re often beautifully decorated with local ceramics and textiles. While more expensive than Ischia’s equivalent offerings, they’re still significantly more affordable than Capri’s luxury hotels while maintaining excellent locations near major attractions.

See Related: Unforgettable Religious Tours in Italy: Transform Your Faith Journey in the Jubilee Year

Leisure and Activities

Both islands offer amazing ways to spend your time, but they differ greatly in what you can do. Capri tends to focus on luxury experiences and scenic spots, while Ischia provides more variety with its thermal waters and larger landscape.

Beaches and Swimming

Ischia wins the beach competition, hands down. With its 46 square kilometers, the island boasts several sandy beaches that are perfect for swimming. Maronti Beach, stretching for nearly 3 kilometers, is one of the most popular spots where you can enjoy the warm sand between your toes.

Capri, being smaller at just 10 square kilometers, offers fewer beaches and they’re mostly rocky or pebbled. Marina Piccola is a gorgeous spot with crystal-clear blue waters, but don’t expect sandy shores here.

Swimming conditions differ, too. Ischia’s beaches slope gently into the water, making them family-friendly.

Capri’s swimming spots often require climbing down rocky paths but reward you with incredible water clarity. Both islands have boat tours and swimming excursions that take you to hidden coves and grottos only accessible by water.

Hiking and Exploration

Hiking enthusiasts will find plenty to love on both islands. Capri’s famous Sentiero dei Fortini (Path of Forts) offers breathtaking coastal views as you walk between ancient fortifications. The climb to Monte Solaro gives you panoramic views of the Bay of Naples.

Ischia, being larger, provides more varied hiking options. Mount Epomeo, the island’s highest point, offers a challenging trek with rewards of spectacular views across the entire Gulf of Naples. The Green Mountain, as locals call it, stands at 789 meters.

Both islands have charming towns to explore. Capri has just two main centers – Capri Town and Anacapri.

Ischia boasts six distinct towns, each with its own character and charm. Compared to Capri’s tourist hotspots, Ischia’s villages have fewer crowds. Walking through Capri’s narrow streets feels more exclusive but can be crowded in peak season.

Spa Treatments and Thermal Springs

This is where Ischia truly shines. Known as the “Green Island,” Ischia sits on volcanic soil that naturally heats numerous thermal springs. The island has been a health destination since Roman times because of these healing waters.

Thermal Gardens like Poseidon and Negombo offer day passes that allow you to hop between pools of different temperatures. Each garden has its own unique setting, with Negombo built into a beautiful bay.

Capri doesn’t have natural thermal waters but compensates with luxury spas in its high-end hotels. These focus more on beauty treatments than healing waters.

For an authentic experience, try the natural hot springs at Sorgeto in Ischia, where hot water bubbles right up through the sea floor. You can book specialized spa treatments on either island, but Ischia offers more affordable options with genuine thermal benefits.

Dining and Cuisine

Both Capri and Ischia offer incredible food experiences that showcase the best of Mediterranean flavors. The islands differ in their dining scenes, with distinct price points and atmospheres catering to different travelers.

Local Gastronomy

Capri’s cuisine revolves around seafood and locally grown produce. The island is famous for its insalata caprese (tomato, mozzarella, and basil), ravioli caprese (cheese-filled pasta with marjoram), and torta caprese (chocolate almond cake). Seafood is a highlight, with restaurants offering freshly caught fish prepared simply with olive oil and lemon.

Ischia’s food scene embraces more rustic, traditional dishes. The island is known for coniglio all’ischitana (rabbit stew), a centuries-old specialty cooked with tomatoes, garlic, and herbs. Seafood is equally important here, often appearing in pasta dishes like spaghetti with sea urchins.

Both islands produce excellent wines. Capri has its white wine, while Ischia boasts several vineyards producing unique varieties like Biancolella and Per’e Palummo.

Authentic Eateries

Capri’s dining scene tends toward the upscale. The island features many fine dining establishments, particularly around the Piazzetta and Marina Grande.

Prices can be steep, especially in tourist hotspots. Many restaurants cater to international visitors, with menus in multiple languages and staff who speak English.

Ischia offers a more diverse range of options. Family-run trattorias serving home-style cooking at reasonable prices can be found alongside fancier establishments. The island generally provides better value, with authentic meals costing less than on its glamorous neighbor.

For a truly local experience in either place, venture away from the main tourist areas. In Ischia’s inland villages, you’ll discover humble eateries where nonna still cooks in the kitchen. In Capri, some hidden gems still exist, but you’ll need to search more diligently.

Shopping and Leisure

Both Capri and Ischia offer distinct shopping experiences that reflect their individual character. While Capri leans toward high-end boutiques, Ischia provides more authentic local markets where you can find unique handcrafted items at better prices.

Boutique Stores

Capri is famous for its luxury shopping scene. The island’s main town features a collection of designer boutiques along Via Camerelle, often called the “Fashion Avenue” of Capri. Here, international brands like Prada, Gucci, and Louis Vuitton are nestled among local Italian designers.

The handcrafted sandals of Capri deserve special mention. These beautiful leather shoes are made to measure while you wait—a perfect souvenir from your trip! Many shops also sell locally made perfumes and limoncello.

Ischia’s boutique scene is more modest but still charming. The main shopping streets in Ischia Porto and Forio offer some nice clothing stores and jewelry shops. Prices here are generally lower than in Capri, making it easier to find unique items without breaking the bank.

Local Markets

Ischia shines when it comes to authentic local markets. The island hosts several weekly markets where you can browse everything from fresh produce to handcrafted ceramics. The Thursday market in Forio is particularly popular with both locals and tourists.

What makes Ischia’s markets special is the genuine connection to local artisans. You’ll find beautiful ceramics featuring the bright colors of the Sorrentine Peninsula, handwoven baskets, and textiles made using traditional methods.

Capri’s markets are smaller and less frequent. The most notable is the small produce market in the main square of Anacapri. While charming, it doesn’t offer the variety found in Ischia’s markets.

For food shopping, both islands offer delightful local specialties. In Ischia, don’t miss the chance to purchase locally-produced honey, olive oil, and wine directly from small producers.

See Related: 10 Day Italy Trip Cost: Budget Your Dream Vacation

Nightlife and Entertainment

When comparing evening activities on these Italian islands, you’ll find distinct experiences. Capri offers glamorous, cosmopolitan nightlife, while Ischia provides more laid-back entertainment options with local charm.

Lounges and Nightclubs

Capri’s nightlife centers around the famous Piazzetta, the island’s main square that transforms into a buzzing social hub after dark. Here, well-heeled visitors sip cocktails at outdoor cafés and watch the parade of fashionable people. The prices match the upscale atmosphere – expect to pay premium rates for drinks and entry to exclusive venues.

For those seeking more lively entertainment, Capri has several sophisticated nightclubs, like Anema e Core. Here, celebrities and locals dance together until dawn. The vibe is decidedly cosmopolitan, with DJs spinning tracks for an international crowd.

Ischia offers a more relaxed nightlife scene. The island has fewer high-end clubs but more authentic bars where you can enjoy reasonably priced drinks alongside locals. Popular areas include Ischia Porto and Forio, where seaside bars provide perfect sunset views.

Cultural Events

Capri hosts elegant cultural evenings throughout the summer season. Classical music concerts take place in stunning settings like Villa San Michele and the Gardens of Augustus. The island also features art exhibitions and fashion shows that attract a sophisticated crowd.

Theater performances and literary festivals add to the cultural calendar, often showcasing Italian talent against beautiful backdrops. Ischia emphasizes its thermal heritage with spa-related evening events and wellness activities. The island hosts traditional folk music performances in town squares and local festivals celebrating island customs.

Open-air cinema screenings and music concerts occur in historic venues across Ischia’s six towns during summer. These events often highlight the island’s rich history and cultural traditions, providing visitors with authentic Italian experiences.

Target Audience and Travel Style

Both islands cater to different types of travelers. Your personal preferences, travel companions, and vacation goals will largely determine which island suits you better.

Family-Friendly Offerings

Ischia wins hands down for families with children. Its larger size (46 square kilometers compared to Capri’s 10) means more space to explore and fewer crowds. Kids will love Ischia’s sandy beaches with gentle slopes into the water—much more practical than Capri’s rocky shores.

The thermal parks are a unique hit with families. Places like Poseidon Gardens offer multiple pools of different temperatures where children can splash while parents relax. Many hotels in Ischia also cater specifically to families with kid-friendly menus and activities.

Transportation is easier in Ischia, too. The bus system connects all six towns, making stroller navigation simpler. Restaurants tend to be more welcoming to little ones, with earlier dining options and child portions available.

Romantic Getaways for Couples

Capri shines as a romantic destination. The island’s intimate size creates a cozy atmosphere perfect for couples. Luxury boutique hotels and B&Bs offer privacy and personalized service that honeymooners and couples appreciate.

The famous Blue Grotto boat tours provide unforgettable romantic moments. For an extra special experience, book a private boat tour around the island at sunset. Many restaurants offer candlelit dinner settings with breathtaking views.

Ischia offers a different kind of romance. Couples can enjoy thermal spa treatments together or find secluded beaches away from crowds. The prices tend to be more reasonable than Capri, making it ideal for couples on a budget.

Evening walks in Ischia Porto or Sant’Angelo provide a more authentic Italian atmosphere with fewer tourists competing for space.

Solo and Adventure Travel

Active solo travelers might prefer Ischia’s varied landscape. Hiking Mount Epomeo offers stunning panoramic views. The island’s network of trails connects small villages where you can stop for authentic meals.

Ischia’s thermal waters attract wellness-focused solo travelers. Each day, you can hop between different spa facilities and healing springs. The locals are accustomed to tourists but not overwhelmed by them, creating opportunities for genuine interactions.

Capri works well for short solo visits. Everything is walkable, and the concentrated tourist areas make it easy to meet other travelers. However, prices run high for single accommodations.

Both islands offer water activities like kayaking and snorkeling, though Ischia provides more varied options due to its larger coastline and fewer crowds competing for rental equipment.

See Related: What to Pack for Italy: Essential Gear for Your Dream Mediterranean Getaway

Frequently Asked Questions

Travelers often wonder about specific differences between these two beautiful Italian islands. Both have unique charms that appeal to different types of visitors depending on what you’re looking for in your Italian getaway.

More Travel Guides