Pelino’s Pasta

Description

As someone who’s eaten their fair share of pasta across the US, I can tell ya that Pelino’s Pasta stands out as a gem that brings real Italian cooking right to your plate. Y’know, it’s one of those places where you can actually taste the difference between mass-produced pasta and the handcrafted stuff. The moment you walk in, you’re hit with this amazing aroma of fresh pasta being made – it’s basically what I imagine heaven smells like.

Their signature cacio e pepe is absolutely mind-blowing. Real talk – I’ve had this dish in Rome, and Pelino’s version holds its own. The sauce is perfectly creamy without being heavy, and they nail that peppery kick every single time. But here’s the thing that really gets me: watching the pasta makers work their magic through the open kitchen. It’s like dinner and a show!

The space itself isn’t huge, which honestly adds to its charm. It feels like those intimate family-run spots you’d stumble upon in a tiny Italian village. The walls are decorated with black and white photos of Italian scenes, and the lighting creates this cozy vibe that makes you wanna linger over your meal.

Key Features

• House-made fresh pasta prepared daily
• Open kitchen where you can watch pasta being made
• Authentic cacio e pepe that’ll transport you straight to Rome
• Seasonal menu that changes based on available ingredients
• Intimate dining space with only about 40 seats
• Family recipes passed down through generations
• Wine list featuring Italian varietals
• Fresh-baked focaccia served with every meal
• Handcrafted desserts including traditional tiramisu
• Special pasta-making workshops on select weekends

Best Time to Visit

Look, I’m gonna level with you – this place gets packed! Your best bet is to hit it up during off-peak hours. Tuesday through Thursday evenings tend to be less crowded, especially if you can make it before 6:30 PM. Weekend brunches are amazing but crazy busy, so if you’re thinking Saturday or Sunday, try to get there right when they open at 11 AM.

During winter months, particularly January and February, it’s easier to snag a table without much wait. And here’s a pro tip I learned the hard way: their lunch service is seriously underrated and way less crowded than dinner. Plus, the natural lighting during daytime makes for some great food photos!

How to Get There

Getting to Pelino’s is pretty straightforward. If you’re driving, there’s street parking available, but it can be tricky during peak hours. I usually park a couple blocks away and enjoy the short walk – helps build up an appetite!

Public transit works great too – several bus lines stop within a few blocks. And if you’re taking a rideshare, just make sure to specify which entrance you want since the restaurant has both a main entrance and a side door.

For cyclists (like myself), there’s a bike rack right outside, and the area is pretty bike-friendly. Just remember to bring a good lock – this is still a city, after all!

Tips for Visiting

Okay, here’s where I’m gonna share some real insider knowledge. First off, reservations are your friend. Seriously. I can’t stress this enough – especially for dinner service. They take bookings up to a month in advance, and trust me, you’ll want to plan ahead.

The portions here are generous (thank goodness!), but don’t let that stop you from trying multiple dishes. My strategy? Go with a small group so you can share and taste more items. The antipasti are particularly amazing, so don’t skip those.

If you’re a pasta purist, try their dishes without modifications first. These folks know what they’re doing, and each recipe has been perfected over time. That said, they’re super accommodating if you have dietary restrictions – just mention it when booking.

Oh, and one more thing – they’ve got this secret off-menu pasta that they only make in limited quantities each day. It’s not always available, but if they have it, GET IT. Just ask your server what the “special pasta of the day” is.

Don’t rush your meal here – Italian dining is meant to be savored. Budget at least 1.5 hours for dinner. And if you’re into learning about what you’re eating, chat with the staff! They’re passionate about their craft and love sharing their knowledge about Italian cuisine.

The complimentary focaccia? It’s amazing, but pace yourself. There’s nothing worse than filling up on bread (even though it’s incredibly tempting) and not having room for their incredible pasta. And please, for the love of all things Italian, save room for dessert. Their tiramisu has made grown adults cry – in a good way!

Location

Places to Stay Near Pelino's Pasta

Find Tours in Columbus

Explore More Travel Guides